I think you've got the talent to be a truly amazing alchemist! You did so well with my other challenge.

Player: "Thanks."

I think I need a greater test of your abilities to see if you're really an Expert.

Would you make Vidar's Noble Spellbook and bring it to me? It requires more skill to make than Vidar's Spellbook, but I know you can make a noble one.

Player: Accept.

The gold embossing's the hard part. Not to mention it'll take some fine calligraphy. But I know you can pull it off!

Player: "I'll do my best!"

Well, how'd you do?

Player: "Take a look."

This book's no good! The writing's really sloppy, and the binding could fall apart at any moment!

I know you can do much, much better than this, Player.

Player: "I thought I did okay...."

Wow, this is great! Look at that craftsmanship!

I knew you had what it took to go all the way! You're truly an Expert in Alchemy!